The first "official" review
- JensJohansson
- Administrator
- Posts:1490
- Joined:Thu Feb 28, 2002 10:45 pm
- Contact:
http://www.bravewords.com/hardwares/1001449
It makes me happy, it's a bad omen if the first published review is horribly bad.
Hopefully more people will like it... but of course, not everyone will. That's how life is.
It makes me happy, it's a bad omen if the first published review is horribly bad.
Hopefully more people will like it... but of course, not everyone will. That's how life is.
Re: The first "official" review
cool review, what is he thinking about the lyric thing though?
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:304
- Joined:Sat Apr 26, 2008 9:10 am
Re: The first "official" review
I don't think it's a negative review, which is good. In fact, they don't really state much of an opinion on it.
And the score is a 7.0/10. I don't know how that score is in Europe, but in a lot of places in the US, it is considered good. Not amazing, but good.
And the score is a 7.0/10. I don't know how that score is in Europe, but in a lot of places in the US, it is considered good. Not amazing, but good.
-
- Jr. Member
- Posts:16
- Joined:Thu Jun 19, 2008 8:26 pm
- Location:Sweden
Re: The first "official" review
Good review. I wouldn't call "Emancipation Suite Part 1" a ballad though..
-> www.metalcentral.net <-
- browneyedgirl
- Sr. Member
- Posts:27239
- Joined:Thu Aug 29, 2002 6:00 pm
- Location:Starfall
- Contact:
Re: The first "official" review
7/10 is pretty good. What did they give the other StratoAlbums?
Reviews are more or less the reviewers opinion, so when they give mediocre scores its nothing to really take seriously. Reviewers try to be objective, but its the nature of reviews to give a heart-felt opinion.
I have read reviews where Elements got, like a 5/10. Some others gave a 8/10. So, review scores are just reference points, so to speak.
Reviews are more or less the reviewers opinion, so when they give mediocre scores its nothing to really take seriously. Reviewers try to be objective, but its the nature of reviews to give a heart-felt opinion.
I have read reviews where Elements got, like a 5/10. Some others gave a 8/10. So, review scores are just reference points, so to speak.
Re: The first "official" review
That part seems so troll. I mean with King being about kings and wars of Sweden, tolkki hardly fits that description unless Jens somehow thinks that tolkki is the reincarnation of a Swedish king. With a song called emancipation, what does the guy expect the lyrics to have, and why would he assume it was something about the band?more than a few of Timo Kotipelto’s lyrics seem to skewer his former bandmate, including ‘King Of Nothing’ (utilizing jackbooted marching sound effect), ‘Blind’ and the aforementioned Emancipations (“It’s time to break these chains and head to freedom. I will be free”).
Re: The first "official" review
What is your review of the album! You know we are dying to know !Metalcentral wrote:Good review. I wouldn't call "Emancipation Suite Part 1" a ballad though..
SHINE ON!
- NightScreamer
- Sr. Member
- Posts:582
- Joined:Tue Mar 03, 2009 6:02 am
Re: The first "official" review
because i have never heard it i always think of king of nothing with kiss of judas lyrics and tune:
the knight awaiiiiiits
the king of nooothiiiiiiing, holds me me once again
the knight awaiiiiiits
the king of nooothiiiiiiing, holds me me once again
Re: The first "official" review
Every review is a bit on the bias side, however I agree with jens in the fact that if good reviews are outweighing the bad ones that is a good sign.
metal feeds the beast
- JensJohansson
- Administrator
- Posts:1490
- Joined:Thu Feb 28, 2002 10:45 pm
- Contact:
Re: The first "official" review
The copies for the reviewers don't have lyric sheets, and apparently the information about who wrote what fell out from the promo copy sleeves.icecab21 wrote:That part seems so troll. I mean with King being about kings and wars of Sweden, tolkki hardly fits that description unless Jens somehow thinks that tolkki is the reincarnation of a Swedish king. With a song called emancipation, what does the guy expect the lyrics to have, and why would he assume it was something about the band?more than a few of Timo Kotipelto’s lyrics seem to skewer his former bandmate, including ‘King Of Nothing’ (utilizing jackbooted marching sound effect), ‘Blind’ and the aforementioned Emancipations (“It’s time to break these chains and head to freedom. I will be free”).
You remembered the story of the Deluge of Poland, that's great The Polish leadership overreached and miscalculated heavily too. Their empire really was the one that was most heavily decimated...
- Bathory Killcraft
- Member
- Posts:290
- Joined:Thu Apr 11, 2002 4:56 pm
Re: The first "official" review
Ey Nightscreamer stop using my @#!!!@#@#avatar!NightScreamer wrote:because i have never heard it i always think of king of nothing with kiss of judas lyrics and tune:
the knight awaiiiiiits
the king of nooothiiiiiiing, holds me me once again
Black Metal is the game I play cos' no one shows me the right way...
Re: The first "official" review
I wonder what the guy will be thinking when he finds out who wrote what and the lyrics? It looks like everyone came up with some pretty interesting stuff.The copies for the reviewers don't have lyric sheets, and apparently the information about who wrote what fell out from the promo copy sleeves.
Re: The first "official" review
I think it's a very very good review. Damn, I can't wait to get the album! . This part is a complete hyyyppeeee!
Introducing virtually every tune, keyboardist Jens Johansson appears to have benefited most from the lineup shuffle, playing a more prominent role in the music. Greater use of backing vocals from other members too. The concluding ‘When Mountains Fall’ is a grand finale, complete with orchestral strings and acoustic guitar.
...Faster than light, higher than the sky, stronger than steel...We´re the legions of the Twilight...
Re: The first "official" review
:luv1: I read the review and its getting more and more excited for this album! ALL HAIL POLARIS!
SHINE ON!
Re: The first "official" review
I work myself for a french webzine : www.leseternels.net
How can I contact your new label (earMusic?) for reviewing Polaris?
How can I contact your new label (earMusic?) for reviewing Polaris?
Mad Butcher & Eternal Devastation
Worst of All Horrendous Post-Makers From Hell
Worst of All Horrendous Post-Makers From Hell
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:3660
- Joined:Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:05 pm
Re: The first "official" review
The review sounds great! I can't wait! This and the Heaven and Hell Album are my most anticipated albums of 2009!
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:304
- Joined:Sat Apr 26, 2008 9:10 am
Re: The first "official" review
I've heard the Heaven & Hell album (I got a promo because I write reviews for a local Newspaper and its website). And it is very good. A bit too slow, but anyone who enjoys the old school Sabbath Doom Metal will adore "The Devil You Know."Ragehead91 wrote:The review sounds great! I can't wait! This and the Heaven and Hell Album are my most anticipated albums of 2009!
Re: The first "official" review
This year is going to kick ass when it comes to metal, I believe 2009 is THE year for metal.
metal feeds the beast
- NeverendingAbyss
- Sr. Member
- Posts:4840
- Joined:Mon Sep 29, 2008 10:41 pm
- Location:Betty White will outlive the queen.
Re: The first "official" review
He's not the only one!!!11!!11!111Bathory Killcraft wrote:Ey Nightscreamer stop using my @#!!!@#@#avatar!NightScreamer wrote:because i have never heard it i always think of king of nothing with kiss of judas lyrics and tune:
the knight awaiiiiiits
the king of nooothiiiiiiing, holds me me once again
What the fuck did you just fucking say about me, you little bitch?!
- NeverendingAbyss
- Sr. Member
- Posts:4840
- Joined:Mon Sep 29, 2008 10:41 pm
- Location:Betty White will outlive the queen.
Re: The first "official" review
I agree completely on that!hiro23 wrote:This year is going to kick ass when it comes to metal, I believe 2009 is THE year for metal.
What the fuck did you just fucking say about me, you little bitch?!
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:3660
- Joined:Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:05 pm
Re: The first "official" review
Old Sabbath Doom Metal with Dio? :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1:Star_Ocean wrote:I've heard the Heaven & Hell album (I got a promo because I write reviews for a local Newspaper and its website). And it is very good. A bit too slow, but anyone who enjoys the old school Sabbath Doom Metal will adore "The Devil You Know."Ragehead91 wrote:The review sounds great! I can't wait! This and the Heaven and Hell Album are my most anticipated albums of 2009!
Re: The first "official" review
This is funny, seems a lot of people are using the same picture now
I've got a huge amount of albums I need to get this year.
I've got a huge amount of albums I need to get this year.
metal feeds the beast
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:3660
- Joined:Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:05 pm
Re: The first "official" review
The Bathory army is taking over!
- Bathory Killcraft
- Member
- Posts:290
- Joined:Thu Apr 11, 2002 4:56 pm
Re: The first "official" review
Ahem... what is going on?! Seems like an organised conspiracy here...Hope not everyone in the forum turns up with a Bathory avatar now...though now that I think of it...how cool would that be!NeverendingAbyss wrote:
He's not the only one!!!11!!11!111
Black Metal is the game I play cos' no one shows me the right way...
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:304
- Joined:Sat Apr 26, 2008 9:10 am
Re: The first "official" review
It's not pure Doom Metal a la Warpigs, but it is definitely closer to that than say, The Mob Rules. Imagine a mixture of old school Sabbath with the Heaven & Hell album, with Dio's voice.Old Sabbath Doom Metal with Dio?
Anyways, is anyone getting a really happy and positive vibe from the sound clips? I am, and not just because of the music. Even if I end up not liking the music, it is still giving off a great vibe that is making me happy.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:580
- Joined:Tue Feb 22, 2005 11:11 pm
- Location:Los Angeles, California
Re: The first "official" review
I think the review is written horribly. "Timo Tolkki the least loved or visible?" I like how he decides who is the most or least loved and how we will like it. And he calls the band finns when in fact only 60% of the band are finns.
Glad you're happy about the review though Jens.
Glad you're happy about the review though Jens.
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:3660
- Joined:Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:05 pm
Re: The first "official" review
:luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1: :luv1:Star_Ocean wrote:It's not pure Doom Metal a la Warpigs, but it is definitely closer to that than say, The Mob Rules. Imagine a mixture of old school Sabbath with the Heaven & Hell album, with Dio's voice.Old Sabbath Doom Metal with Dio?
Re: The first "official" review
I never really pay much attention to album reviews, they are nothing more than someone's personal opinion. Like hiro23 said, they will always be biased. Some of my favorite albums have got terrible reviews I mean really, who cares what some journalist who got their copy for free thinks?
Re: The first "official" review
What matters really is what the fans think and also what the band thinks.
You know you've got a great album if the majority of your fans have got a copy of it, you know you have a classic album if not only many of your fans have it but also some people who've never even heard of the band before.
You know you've got a great album if the majority of your fans have got a copy of it, you know you have a classic album if not only many of your fans have it but also some people who've never even heard of the band before.
metal feeds the beast
Another Review
Well, my webmaster was true to his word and our review of Polaris has been published today.
So, check it out on BeyondEarCandy.com, and as soon as we get the real deal, we'll have the album on the radio as well. Hopefully, some recorded interviews too. Cheers!
So, check it out on BeyondEarCandy.com, and as soon as we get the real deal, we'll have the album on the radio as well. Hopefully, some recorded interviews too. Cheers!
“He who despairs of the human condition is a coward, but he who has hope for it is a fool” A. Camus
Beyond Ear Candy Metal Radio
beyondearcandy.com
Photos from 2008 Winter NAMM and Blog on Ben in Iraq on MySpace myspace.com/ambr_bec
Beyond Ear Candy Metal Radio
beyondearcandy.com
Photos from 2008 Winter NAMM and Blog on Ben in Iraq on MySpace myspace.com/ambr_bec