I liked Polaris, but I think the next album is going to be better. After quite a few listens, I'd rank Polaris only in front of the black album (not taking into account the pre-Kotipelto era albums, which I don't realy consider to be in the same league).
I think there's a consensus about what the community would like to see in the next album. To sum it up:
- Kotipelto singing like he did in Gather The Faithful, i.e., much less agressive, much cleaner, pre-black album. Gather The Faithful reminded me of why I consider him the best power metal voice ever.
- Matias playing heavier. Perhaps heavier isn't the right word here. Maybe Strato wanted to offset for the lack of synth in the black album, and ended up creating songs where the guitar is merely a background element. It's not that the guitar parts were not good enough, they were simply not visible or distinctive enough.
I would like to add the following items to that list:
- Catchy epic songs.
Higher We Go,
Blind and
Forever Is Today are catchy, for example.
Emancipation Suite (both parts) and
King Of Nothing are good epic songs, but they're far from catchy. Compare that to
Destiny or
Infinity, catchy, epic songs.
- Ballads or slower songs in general that send chills down your spine. Destiny is blessed with those, with
4000 Rainy Nights,
Years Go By and
Venus In The Morning). Visions had
Before The Winter and
Coming Home. Episode had
Season Of Change and
Forever. Infinite had
Mother Gaia and
Celestial Dream. Elements had, among others,
Season Of Faith's Perfection,
Liberty. The black album had
The Land Of Ice And Snow. Polaris had
Winter Skies (which is a major masterpiece), then
Somehow Precious (boring to me, way too long, way too cheesy) and
When Mountains Fall (good song, but doesn't stand on its own). I think we could use more catchy ballads like
Winter Skies and
4000 Rainy Nights.
- Deeper lyrics. The lyrics in Polaris are fine (above average, really), but they don't stand out like the lyrics in songs like
Night Time Eclipse,
Season Of Change. I think they're too happy and simple some times. In songs like
I'm Still Alive, even though the message is positive overall, it's about overcoming challenges ("All my life, I've felt like an outcast / But not anymore, a thing of the past! / I'm still alive / I'm ready to feel the wind in my hair / And I know there are so many things to share / I will write my story again / Master plan of a new kind / I was lost but now I'm found / I'm still alive!"). Another good example is
Rebel ("Lost behind the lies / I can hear your cries / Now it's the time to rise again so strong / Learn from your past / But better make it fast / The time is running out for you to change your life / You must learn to live / There's so much more to give / Set fire to your soul again and be the rebel! / Hold your head up high!"). Compare those two songs with similar themes:
Higher We Go: When all is crashing down / I know the time will heal / In this insanity / We'll find what is real! / Together we are so strong / Holding our heads up high / We will carry on / 'Till the day we die!
Hunting High And Low: After the storm there's a calm / Through the clouds shines a ray of the sun / I'm carried from all of my harm / There is no one that I can't outrun / Now I'm leaving my worries behind / Feel the freedom of body and mind / I am starting my journey / I'm drifting away with the wind / I go!
I know this is kind of subjective, but I see a big difference.
Higher We Go has an overconfident view, it's a cellebration of victory already.
Hunting High And Low is more about working hard to overcome problems. It's a cellebration of the journey that will lead you to victory ("Sometimes I may win, sometimes I'll lose / It's just a game that I play"), it seems more humble, realistic and noble.
Also, the lyrics have more content in HHAL. Instead of saying "I know the time will heal", HHAL says "After the storm there's a calm", which is just much prettier. When I listen to HHAL, I imagine a whole scenery due to graphic descriptions like this, and that doesn't happen with HWG.
- Traditional themes. I don't know if that's the best way to describe it.
Winter Skies got it right again in this aspect. Songs about the frozen lakes, the woods, the cold winter nights, the winter breeze, the falling yellow leaves, or the snow that begins to fall. But this goes beyond the lyrics.
All in all, I trust the talent those guys have. Whatever they come up with, I'm dead sure it's gonna be another masterpiece.
