Has Malmsteen copy BlackDiamond in his new album Relentless?

[KupiainenItaly96]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8rftKqu8SA
From 4:50 to 5:18
I don't believe it at least he could copy Hands of Time or Playing with Fire that are not as popular as Black Diamond.
What a shame, too Malmsteen has copied the chorus of The Ancinet Fires of Har-Kuun of Rhapsody of Fire, always in Into Valhalla the copy and paste song.
I'm a great fan of a Malmsteen and i prefer Malmsteen to Stratovarius, but this is a shame!

[Rebel]

woooooow

[KupiainenItaly96]

Rebel don't deny the reality. Malmsteen has copied.

[Rebel]

Rebel don't deny the reality. Malmsteen has copied.

I'm laughing at Malmsteen, he's such a fool

[KupiainenItaly96]

Rebel don't deny the reality. Malmsteen has copied.

I'm laughing at Malmsteen, he's such a fool

I fully agree.

[AGAG]

...

[robocop656]

...

[icecab21]

Black diamond is a basic finger exercise, hardly anything original. Just generic baroque finger exercise. Malmsteen does not even follow the chord progression that black diamond does the finger exercise over. The second part of the phrase is completely different as well.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipzR9bhei_o
let me guess bach stole from black diamond as well

[AGAG]

...

I'm not good at distinguishing things but are those spiked dicks on your avatar?

[ggonza43]

It sounds similar, not saying Yngwie "stole" it, but it may be considered pure coincidence. Besides, I don't think he needs to stole anything from nobody

[adrian9]

Black diamond is a basic finger exercise, hardly anything original. Just generic baroque finger exercise. Malmsteen does not even follow the chord progression that black diamond does the finger exercise over. The second part of the phrase is completely different as well.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipzR9bhei_o
let me guess bach stole from black diamond as well

agreed x10000000 there are many examples of this. before and after black diamond.

[ggonza43]

Some power metal bands uses arrangements originally made by classic music composer...So they actually stole it all !

[robocop656]

I'm not good at distinguishing things but are those spiked dicks on your avatar?

Click on profile and check out the big version of the spiked dicks!!

Some power metal bands uses arrangements originally made by classic music composer...So they actually stole it all !

It ain't actually "stealing" because Bach is in the public domain (am I right?)
:laff: :laff:

[pneumonia]

It's rather taken from Toccata&Fugue in D minor, especially Fugue by Bach.

Bach and Vivaldi are the main influences in a huge part of power metal

[RazielSR]

KupiainenItaly, with this topic and this another one:http://forum.stratovarius.com/viewtopic.php?t=10244 it's clear for me that you are completely fool

Man, there's no copy there.

And Malmsteen ROCKS!

[KupiainenItaly96]

KupiainenItaly, with this topic and this another one:http://forum.stratovarius.com/viewtopic.php?t=10244 it's clear for me that you are completely fool

Man, there's no copy there.

And Malmsteen ROCKS!

And Kenji Yamamoto's topic? It's not crazy?

[foerg]

It's rather taken from Toccata&Fugue in D minor, especially Fugue by Bach.

Bach and Vivaldi are the main influences in a huge part of power metal

you´re so right...

[lalodrums2]

Black diamond is a basic finger exercise, hardly anything original. Just generic baroque finger exercise. Malmsteen does not even follow the chord progression that black diamond does the finger exercise over. The second part of the phrase is completely different as well.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipzR9bhei_o
let me guess bach stole from black diamond as well

I totally agree 100% with you.

In addition, Yngwie always use those notes one song (among a lot) is this... Minute mark 1.40

Cheers to Bach!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzjR1dV0JGc

<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/RzjR1dV0JGc?fs ... ram><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/RzjR1dV0JGc?fs=1&amp;hl=es_MX" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>

[ggonza43]

It ain't actually "stealing" because Bach is in the public domain (am I right?)
:laff: :laff:

He is, if not all power metalers are thieves !

[KupiainenItaly96]

KupiainenItaly, with this topic and this another one:http://forum.stratovarius.com/viewtopic.php?t=10244 it's clear for me that you are completely fool

Man, there's no copy there.

And Malmsteen ROCKS!

@ Raziel I had forgotten to invite you to put a potato in the ass.
Raziel So fuck you.
Go to hell

@Sumerian Fuck also you
Your troll stupid opinion about Tolkki, Stratovarius, Kupiainen and Symfonia are ridicolous.
Be neutral instead of shooting shit

[ggonza43]

@Sumerian Fuck also you
Your troll stupid opinion about Tolkki, Stratovarius, Kupiainen and Symfonia are ridicolous.
Be neutral instead of shooting shit

Sumerian isn't even here !

[KupiainenItaly96]

Yes I know that Sumerian isn't even here, but it's still an asshole

[ggonza43]

Couldn't agree more with you

[KupiainenItaly96]

Couldn't agree more with you

I do not give a fuck
But I respect you ggonza, you are a very Strato-fan, you are publishd all songs of Strato on youtube.

Ggonza OK
Sumerian FUCK!

[thefreeone]

Couldn't agree more with you

I do not give a fuck
But I respect you ggonza, you are a very Strato-fan, you are publishd all songs of Strato on youtube.

Ggonza OK
Sumerian FUCK!

A10 once again?

[ggonza43]

Thanks KupiainenItaly96, and no thefreeone, he isn't A10...As far as I'm concerned

[Intiaani]

Well, I'd say that more than Black Diamond, the particular 4:50 - 5:18 part modifies the main finger exercise melody of this, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XlNbQv_Rg4. I don't even know from which work it is originally; I take from one of Salieri's.

<e> lol, It's from Bach's Toccata and Fugue after all.

[ggonza43]

It's a common finger exercise from most keyboardist, nothing really special and original if you ask me. Besides, I don't think Yngwie had any intention of "copy" this, it was a coincidence

[Intiaani]

Andall his stuff has always been very neoclassical, so that the classical influences really show. It would be nice to see some results of a research which shows whatever Yngwie has plagiarized or loaned, whether by accident or not. I think there might be hundreds of compositions involved.

[ggonza43]

I think there might be hundreds of compositions involved.

And in the other way too