WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
-
- Member
- Posts:61
- Joined:Mon Aug 09, 2004 3:14 am
i think its tolkki because he put his heart on his guitar.....plus he has a great alternate picking technic...what is your opinion?
- browneyedgirl
- Sr. Member
- Posts:27239
- Joined:Thu Aug 29, 2002 6:00 pm
- Location:Starfall
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
I think this question is in the Musician section.........and, Tolkki!
"Your life is yours, and yours alone. Rise up and live it!"
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
-
- Jr. Member
- Posts:2
- Joined:Sun Aug 08, 2004 6:14 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
how about guitar gods??
like Steve Vai, Joe Satriani, Paul Gilbert and Yngwie Malmsteen...
i dun think Tolkki had reached their level yet...
but...
Tolkki is still one of the greatest guitarist that i had known so far
like Steve Vai, Joe Satriani, Paul Gilbert and Yngwie Malmsteen...
i dun think Tolkki had reached their level yet...
but...
Tolkki is still one of the greatest guitarist that i had known so far
Where have all the years gone
That's what I am asking now
What have I learned so far
Tell me Father Time - Tell me now
That's what I am asking now
What have I learned so far
Tell me Father Time - Tell me now
- browneyedgirl
- Sr. Member
- Posts:27239
- Joined:Thu Aug 29, 2002 6:00 pm
- Location:Starfall
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
And, Andrew Bordoni of the band, Earthcubed, is really good, too...So is Chris Poland(he plays for Megadth once again!).
"Your life is yours, and yours alone. Rise up and live it!"
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
- StratoPummi
- Sr. Member
- Posts:2526
- Joined:Sat Jan 18, 2003 3:18 pm
- Location:Kuusankoski ja Kotka
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
This topic again.
Laiho..?
Laiho..?
PA-PE-RI-MASSAA
SUO-RAT HAMPAAT
LAI-HAN TY-TÖN VATSAA POLTTAA!
SUO-RAT HAMPAAT
LAI-HAN TY-TÖN VATSAA POLTTAA!
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Yeah, I have to say too that Laiho is the best
- StratoRico
- Member
- Posts:260
- Joined:Mon Oct 06, 2003 5:24 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
well Petrucci actually is one of the top guitarist because of his thechnique.
He has developed every aspect of guitar playing.
He can play fast,he can play slowly,had good melody etc...
But i still don't like his style.
Romeo and Tolkki are more Malmsteenian even if i think romeo is clearer in thechnique than tolkki.
You can see the difference in the way they move they're fingers on the guitar.
So,if i have to speak in thechnique i will say:
- petrucci
- romeo
- tolkki.
If i have to speak for me,for the style etc...
- tolkki
- romeo
- petrucci
He has developed every aspect of guitar playing.
He can play fast,he can play slowly,had good melody etc...
But i still don't like his style.
Romeo and Tolkki are more Malmsteenian even if i think romeo is clearer in thechnique than tolkki.
You can see the difference in the way they move they're fingers on the guitar.
So,if i have to speak in thechnique i will say:
- petrucci
- romeo
- tolkki.
If i have to speak for me,for the style etc...
- tolkki
- romeo
- petrucci
Make the best out of your dreams.
They're the world where you are free
They're the world where you are free
-
- Administrator
- Posts:54
- Joined:Sat Jul 20, 2002 9:43 am
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
"And mine is bigger than yours"
I think all those guitarists are superior in their own way but I wouldn't even try to put them in any specific order.
Now if you would've had Alexi Laiho of Children of Bodom listed as one of the three, then the decision would've been a bit easier cause WildChild is a maniac with his guitar. Just my opinion.
I think all those guitarists are superior in their own way but I wouldn't even try to put them in any specific order.
Now if you would've had Alexi Laiho of Children of Bodom listed as one of the three, then the decision would've been a bit easier cause WildChild is a maniac with his guitar. Just my opinion.
- StratoHeart
- Sr. Member
- Posts:1324
- Joined:Thu Jun 12, 2003 9:13 pm
- Location:Sabáudia, Brazil
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Who would disagree your opinion, admin, when it's completely right?
Wildchild and COB rules!!!! :headbang:
Wildchild and COB rules!!!! :headbang:
- Twilightsymphony
- Sr. Member
- Posts:1340
- Joined:Thu Sep 26, 2002 10:07 pm
- Location:Wiesdorf, Germany
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Stevie Ray Vaughan of course
No, but i think Petrucci is very impressive, he can really play a wide range of different styles, not just metal or neo classical stuff but also Jazz and Blues elements and very emotional parts (on the older albums), so i think i would vote for him
EDIT: Same for Joe Satriani...
there are so many great, unique guitar players out there, this question is senseless
No, but i think Petrucci is very impressive, he can really play a wide range of different styles, not just metal or neo classical stuff but also Jazz and Blues elements and very emotional parts (on the older albums), so i think i would vote for him
EDIT: Same for Joe Satriani...
there are so many great, unique guitar players out there, this question is senseless
Delusions Of Grandeur
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
I am
Chemistry is physics without a thought
Mathematics is physics without a purpose
Mathematics is physics without a purpose
- StragOvariuS
- Sr. Member
- Posts:950
- Joined:Sat Jul 03, 2004 3:40 am
- Location:Vittu tätä paskaa
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
well...considerating the three mentioned is Romeo...tolkki and petrucci is cool....but c´mon...that fat guy play like hell....romeo kick ass!!! did you all watched his guitarlesson video??? he kills....
Churrasqueiro Reinassance!!!
- LittleHarry
- Member
- Posts:124
- Joined:Thu Jul 22, 2004 6:41 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
ow c`mon andre olbrich is best anyway...
but from the guys petrucci is best...he can play almost everything...
but from the guys petrucci is best...he can play almost everything...
Best Guitar Player
I think it is Timo Tokki because he can play
melodic and speed parts in the same time..
he is a perfectionist
But I think Kirk Hammet and Slash are very good guitar players too :crazy1:
melodic and speed parts in the same time..
he is a perfectionist
But I think Kirk Hammet and Slash are very good guitar players too :crazy1:
- StragOvariuS
- Sr. Member
- Posts:950
- Joined:Sat Jul 03, 2004 3:40 am
- Location:Vittu tätä paskaa
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
well...if is to conisderate all the guitar world...i choose Randy for the craziest solos after zakk wylde...
Churrasqueiro Reinassance!!!
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
What band is that petrucci guy from anyway...
-
- Jr. Member
- Posts:12
- Joined:Sun Aug 08, 2004 7:19 am
- Location:Los Angeles
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
I don't know all the guitar players are very special and very skilled in there own way so it's very hard to relay to the topic but if I had to chose it would have to be tolkki because even though I like Dream Theater. There newalbums aren't as good as there other ones so TOLKKI all the way
- Twilightsymphony
- Sr. Member
- Posts:1340
- Joined:Thu Sep 26, 2002 10:07 pm
- Location:Wiesdorf, Germany
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Dream Theater.. shame on youpYromaniaZ wrote:What band is that petrucci guy from anyway...
Delusions Of Grandeur
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Although Romeo is more technical than Tolkki I feel Tolkki is a much better songwriter (keep in mind I love Symphony X too) and songwriting is always first in my book. I also feel Timo is more emotional than Romeo too
Petrucci's just overrated so I don't talk much about him although I do like a select few Dream Theater albums ...
Petrucci's just overrated so I don't talk much about him although I do like a select few Dream Theater albums ...
- browneyedgirl
- Sr. Member
- Posts:27239
- Joined:Thu Aug 29, 2002 6:00 pm
- Location:Starfall
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Esteban is a great Hispanic guitarist.
From the Past, I have to say the Late Jim Croce can't hardly be beat! I saw a special last night on APT/PBS, and i had also forgotten what a great songwriter/guitar player he was! He was VERY popular when I was a child until a plane crash took his life at only 30 years old(I think).
His greatest songs were: Lover's Cross, Time in a Bottle, Bad Bad LeRoy Brown etc. etc. Many Songs still being played today after 30 years of his death.
From the Past, I have to say the Late Jim Croce can't hardly be beat! I saw a special last night on APT/PBS, and i had also forgotten what a great songwriter/guitar player he was! He was VERY popular when I was a child until a plane crash took his life at only 30 years old(I think).
His greatest songs were: Lover's Cross, Time in a Bottle, Bad Bad LeRoy Brown etc. etc. Many Songs still being played today after 30 years of his death.
"Your life is yours, and yours alone. Rise up and live it!"
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
Bob: I don't believe in God.
Archangel Michael: That's OK, Bob, because He doesn't believe in you, either!~Legion~
-
- Sr. Member
- Posts:410
- Joined:Fri May 10, 2002 8:13 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Richie Blackmore!!! Yngwie alway says you have guitar players and guitar owners.Imo Blackmore is still the the best!!
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
TOLKKI!!without a doubt.He gets all the sentiment on his guitar,draws tears from her,it´s impressive!!if he can´t speak he would be enough his guitar to make oneself understood.He is the Master,the only one,inimitable,WONDERFUL!!!!!I adore him and I only wish,that he recover soon,and that he continue delighting us with his music,that he keep on demonstrating all that he is of value!! :headbang:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
ok everybody votes for tolkki (we are in stratovarius page so this is not a surprise)
BUT, my vote goes for Pretucci, we can do more extensives solos, stunnigs scales , arpeggios and irregular scales. by all of this my vote goes for PRETUCCI.
BUT, my vote goes for Pretucci, we can do more extensives solos, stunnigs scales , arpeggios and irregular scales. by all of this my vote goes for PRETUCCI.
A9
- Stratomano
- Member
- Posts:79
- Joined:Wed Apr 14, 2004 7:00 pm
- Contact:
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
yeah...and technic alsoFakeTolkki wrote:i think its tolkki because he put his heart on his guitar.....plus he has a great alternate picking technic...what is your opinion?
-
- Member
- Posts:61
- Joined:Mon Aug 09, 2004 3:14 am
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
ok petrucci is great and can play extensive complex songs...but PETRUCCI ARPPEGIOUS???? cmon petrucci is good in many technics but he cant make arppeggious....listen to dream theater and you will know that he doesnt do any arpegiou....the only time i saw him making an arppegiou on the metropolis 2000 show he made the dirtiest sound ive ever heard....he is a great guitar player but i dont like exercise musics like.....first part ill do panananananada papa....an there goes the other parts just by mixing the order of the scales....by all this ill say it again...TOLKKI RULEZ!!!!!!!!! but malmsteen is better anyway.....
-
- Jr. Member
- Posts:13
- Joined:Thu Aug 05, 2004 5:46 am
- Location:Ontario, Canada
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Petrucci, easily. He's been my favorite guitarist for a LONG time now.
- Holy Light
- Sr. Member
- Posts:381
- Joined:Thu Dec 11, 2003 1:57 am
- Location:USA
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
STUPID TOPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!! But of course Romeo is the best out of them. I like Tolkki the same. Petrucci isn't shit compared to Romeo! But he is a great player.
-
- Member
- Posts:115
- Joined:Fri Dec 19, 2003 4:29 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
Tolkki rules man!!!!!
Hes the king
Hes the king
- timo the soulforged
- Member
- Posts:256
- Joined:Sat May 22, 2004 1:38 pm
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
i think petrucci is the best but i like tolki's songs more....
-
- Jr. Member
- Posts:4
- Joined:Fri Aug 06, 2004 1:48 am
Re: WHOS THE BEST GUITAR PLAYER, TOLKKI, ROMEU OR PETRUCCI?
IT IS IN MY OWN OPINION THAT PETRUCCI IS THE TOP OF THIS SHORT LIST FROM A LONG LIST OF GREAT PLAYERS TOLKKI IS = LY GREAT IN HIS OWN RIGHT AS FOR ROMEO I DONT KNOW MUCH ABOUT HIM
I CAME TO KICKBUTT AND CHEW BUBBLEGUM
AND I'M ALL OUT OF BUBBLE GUM
AND I'M ALL OUT OF BUBBLE GUM