Stratoplaigarism?

[fifthtea_sausage]

Cellador, No Chances Lost, 4:15.
Sounds exactly like Eagleheart.
COINCIDENCE? I think not!


Official and legit.
http://cellador.com/CELLADOR-No_Chances_Lost_demo.mp3

[Equinox]

It's true! oh.....Neorave would love this!

[Nightmare1z]

Indeed - is the band doing like a tribute to Strato in their song? Kinda like how some bands will put in a classical solo to pay tribute to a classical song.

Still, that is definately Eagleheart in there. Same rhythm timing and everything.

Another good copycat of Strato example is Stratovarius - Playing with fire and At Vance - Only Human. Sounds exactly the same

[Neferte]

It is almost the main melody of Eagleheart. I say almost because there's a very slight variation at some part of the partiture, but, nevertheless... it's Eagleheart! I don't think it's a coincidence, neither. The melody is even repeated a second time, exactly like in the song of Strato. What were those guys of Cellador thinking while playing it? Could it be a tribute? Or something else...?

[NeonVomit]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

[Latuman]

Am I stupid or something cause...

That does not sound at all like Eagleheart. Could someone point out the part where this sounds like Eagleheart?

[Electric Eye]

I agree, maybe there's something wrong with my ears, or you fixed this topic. Don't pull our leg Maybe chorus is a bit simillar, but don't exaggerate...

[Latuman]

Right, after 4mins the guitar melody is half of Eagleheart riff. That not enough to be counted as plagiarism in my opinion.

Sure this isn't very common, but still, not nearly as clear as you said.

How about Stratoplagiarism in Strato's own songs? Compare "I Walk To My Own Song" and "Dreamweaver". Latter has a guitar melody the same than the first ones keyb melody.

[MaFiaBoY]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

[NeonVomit]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

I have to agree with you there. It's one of my least favourite Stratosongs (makes a cunning contrast with Elements pt1, which is one of my favourite Stratoalbums!)

[NeonVomit]

Right, after 4mins the guitar melody is half of Eagleheart riff. That not enough to be counted as plagiarism in my opinion.

Sure this isn't very common, but still, not nearly as clear as you said.

How about Stratoplagiarism in Strato's own songs? Compare "I Walk To My Own Song" and "Dreamweaver". Latter has a guitar melody the same than the first ones keyb melody.

It's different if the same band takes its own work and imitates it in another song, especially in the same album. That's just called making connections within the work.

[MaFiaBoY]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

I have to agree with you there. It's one of my least favourite Stratosongs (makes a cunning contrast with Elements pt1, which is one of my favourite Stratoalbums!)

In fact I like Eagleheart quite much, very catchy with nice melodies and a very powerful chorus. But I have to admit it is not very inventive.

[Stratofanius]

It's one of my least favourite Stratosongs (makes a cunning contrast with Elements pt1, which is one of my favourite Stratoalbums!)

Well, I think too that it's one of my least favourite stratosongs AND Elements pt.1 is the worst stratoalbum after Fright Night.

[Equinox]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

I agree too, but Eagleheart is a good song IMO, I never skip it.

[Aresius]

jaja teh same melody. The singer sounds just like tobias sammet:|

[Beast_Pete]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

I agree too, but Eagleheart is a good song IMO, I never skip it.

Same here.

[NeonVomit]

In fact I like Eagleheart quite much, very catchy with nice melodies and a very powerful chorus. But I have to admit it is not very inventive.

I don't dislike the song. I think it is, unto itself, a good song. I just don't like it as much as other songs because it's WAY too much like Hunting High And Low.

Seeing as Elements Pt 1 is nothing like any other Strato albums, I thought it wasn't a great choice as a single, since it wasn't representative of the album's style.

But what the hell do I know. I'm just an idiot who posts on a forum

[StratoHeart]

I opened a topic exactly with the same name some time ago and people almost killed me... Freedom Call has two songs which brings to my mind StratoSongs:

Holy Knight, the chorus' riff sounds like the ones on the Fright Night introduction

And the song HHAL also sounds like the same-named StratoSong. And the name has nothing to do with this opinion.

[Mormegil]

jaja teh same melody. The singer sounds just like tobias sammet:|

And Sammet sounds just like Bruce Dickinson and Michael Kiske.

The melody of Eagleheart is quite simple, so it can easily be an accident.

[Equinox]

I opened a topic exactly with the same name some time ago and people almost killed me.

Sorry.....couldn't resist.



I never have found songs that sound like Stratovarius'
I'll try to get Freedom Call's.

[kolcer]

I hope its a tribute. It's either that or its indicative of an extreme lack of creativity.

Eagleheart is already one of the lest creative stratosongs, they could have chosen a better song to copy

I agree too, but Eagleheart is a good song IMO, I never skip it.

Me too. In fact this is the first Stratovarius song I ever heard, and though there are better ones, this is one of my favourites.

Btw, I've listend to it several times (No Chances Lost) and that dosen't sound like Eagleheart. Or i'm just tone deaf.

[CottonCandy]

There is no copyright on "ideas" and,"sounds similar" is an opinionated/subjective phrase, so plagerism is a very hard thing to prove. Harder than illegimate paternity used to be in the Dark Ages! In other words, its a free market and groups will get ideas from others, even unconciously, so we should not worry about it.


btw, I can't spell good so forgive my posts at times.

[Solberg]

it's quite similar to eagleheart, i don't think it's like a tribute...it sounds like an own melody to it's song (inspired in eaglehart )

[Aresius]

There is no copyright on "ideas" and,"sounds similar" is an opinionated/subjective phrase, so plagerism is a very hard thing to prove. Harder than illegimate paternity used to be in the Dark Ages! In other words, its a free market and groups will get ideas from others, even unconciously, so we should not worry about it.


btw, I can't spell good so forgive my posts at times.

Hehehe if it was illegal we yngwie malmsteen..ect should be in jail because most of their music has clasical fragments

[fifthtea_sausage]

Bach didn't copyright anything.

And there is a difference between being influenced by someone and outright copying the exact melody and throwing in a similar bass line.

[edited for niceness by fifth, because I care]

[Aresius]

What the fuck are you talking about man? probably you didnt understund what the fuck i put so why do you have to talk shit....

besides, there is no difference there are a LOT of malmsteen fragments that use the exactly same melody in the same key that soem bach, paganini songs and im just saying that its cool and you come out and start talking shit...

sory but i

[fifthtea_sausage]

Yes, but once again, Bach never copyrighted anything ...so there is a difference between using classical fragments and blatantly plaigarizing modern ones.

[NeonVomit]

True. There is a big difference between taking somthing that was composed over 300 years ago, and copying something that is copywrited and was released 2 years ago.

[Solberg]

please!!!!!!! how could you say that if Bach, Mozart or whoever compose that, didn't copyright anything, you can use it in in your songs????????
let's face it....modern (power or melodic) metal is lacking original melodies...groups use very similar melodies...i am not surprised by new groups who introduce these similar melodies

[Jabi]

That piece of melody is old. It's not like nobody had never used it before Eagleheart.