Page 1 of 7
Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 2:01 pm
by Paulo
If you could make up your own all-stars band from members of other bands, who would be in it? Post who would be playing what, and which bands they are originally from. So for example mine would be:
Drums: Dan Zimmerman (Gamma Ray)
Guitars: Alexi Laiho (Children of Bodom)
Guitars: Herman Li (Dragonforce)
Keyboards: Jens Johanson (Stratovarius)
Bass: Dirk Schlachter (Gamma Ray)
Vocals: Tobias Sammet (Edguy)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 2:04 pm
by Pikkusielu
I would include Jari Mäenpää to my all-star band, but otherwise it would be more or less Stratovarius.
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 2:24 pm
by htcdude
We had this topic a while ago, DragonForce

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 2:25 pm
by StragOvariuS
vocals: Lemmy Kilmister
bass: Cliff Burton (its valid put dead musicians?)
guitars: Fast Eddie Clark and Steve Vai
drums: Dave Lombardo
keys or piano: Jens Johansson
i mean...that would be rock n' roll till die!
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 2:53 pm
by Bones
Vocals: Ronnie James Dio (Dio, Black Sabbath, Rainbow, Elf)
Drums: William Ward (Black Sabbath)
Guitar: Randy Rhoads (Ozzy Osbourne, Quiet Riot)
Guitar: Dave Murray (Iron Maiden)
Bass: Cliff Burton (Metallica)
Keyboards: Jens Johansson (Stratovarius)
It's so difficult to choose guitar players so i had to put there two

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 3:25 pm
by Cristiane
well, my band would have basically helloween and Strato members
Drums: Jörg Michael (Stratovarius) or maybe Thomas Stausch (ex Blind Guardian)
Guitars: Timo Tolkki (Stratovarius)
Guitars: Michael Weikath (Helloween)
Keyboards: Jens Johansson (Stratovarius)
Bass: Markus Grosskopf (Helloween)
Vocals: Bruce Dickinson (Iron Maiden) or Steve Perry (ex Journey)
man, Weiki and TT in the same band would kick so much ass

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 4:07 pm
by CottonCandy
SINGER---Timo Kotipelto
GUITAR1--TT
GUITAR2--Andrew Bordoni
DRUMS--Lars, or Jorg Michael
KEYBOARD--Jens, of course!
BASS--Dave Ellefson
Back-up Singer--Kristin Lamb, or Robin Wiper
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 4:36 pm
by Stratofanius
Too hard question. I have so many different persons to put there. But:
Vocals: Bruce Dickinson or Timo Kotipelto
Bass: Steve Harris
Keyboards: Jens Johansson
Drums: Jörg Michael
Guitar: I really can't decide! There are too many!
But there are so many bands in this world that this can change any time

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 6:28 pm
by Elazul
Mhhm pretty difficult to choose:
Vocals : Tobias Sammet (Edguy, Avantasia)
EDIT =
Vocals: Tarja Turunen ò__ó
Guitars 1 : Michael Romeo (Symphony X)
Guitars 2 : Stephan Forte (Adagio)
Drums : Jörg Michael (you know him

)
Keyboards : Jens Johansson (you know him too

)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 6:53 pm
by neonlightchild
i've already post this in another topic a while ago, but...nevermind
In a melodic metal band:
Vocals: Tony Kakko(Sonata Arctica)
Guitar: Michael Romeo (Symphony X)
Guitar: Kiko Loureiro (Angra)
Bass: Billy Sheehan (Vai)
Drums: Ulli Kusch (Masterplan)
For a melodic death metal band:
Vocals: Thomas Lindberg (Ex- At the Gates, Lock Up)
Guitar: Michael Amott (Arch Enemy)
Guitar: Martin Henriksson (Dark Tranquillity)
Bass: Steve DiGiorgio (Ex-Death)
Drums: Anders Jivarp (Dark Tranquillity)
For trash:
Vocals: Max Cavalera (Soulfly)
Guitar: Dave Mustaine (Megadeth)
Guitar: Kerry King (Slayer)
Bass: David Ellefson (Ex-Megadeth)
Drums: Dave Lombardo (Slayer)
That's it

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2005 9:42 pm
by fifthtea_sausage
Guitar 1: John Petrucci (Dream Theater)
Guitar 2: Yngwie Malmsteen (Rising Force)
Vocals: Tony Kakko (Sonata Arctica)
Drums: Dave Mackintosh/Anders Johansson (Dragonforce/Hammerfall) [Mafiaboy isn't going to be happy about this

]
Keyboards: Jens Johansson, Derek Sherinian (Stratovarius/Dream Theater)
Bass: Cliff Burton, Lauri Porra (Metallica, Stratovarius):D
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 6:58 am
by Chronologo
there are many ways to make an all star metal band, here is one of mine
drums : Jörg Michael (

? XD ) or Ingo Schwichtenberg ( Helloween, RIP, this is a tribute to you Ingo )
vocals : Andi Deris ( Helloween ) or Kotipelto ( Strato! )
guitar 1 : Timo Tolkki ( Stratovarius ) or Lucca Turilli ( Rhapsody )
guitar 2 : Kai Hansen ( Gamma Ray ) or Michael Weikath ( Helloween )
look this 2 bassists!
bass 1 : Markus Grosskopf ( Helloween )
bass 2 : Patrice Gvers ( Rhapsody )
keyboards : Jens Johansson ( Stratovarius ) or Alex Staropoli ( Rhapsody )
this is more likely for a power melodic metal band
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 8:10 am
by Inventariado
Perfect Band:
Guitar: Timo Tolkki
Drums: Jörg Michael
Keyboards: Jens Johansson
Bass: Jari Kainulainen
Vocals: Timo Kotipelto / Michael Kiske / Mark Boals
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 6:10 pm
by CottonCandy
Inventariado wrote:Perfect Band:
Guitar: Timo Tolkki
Drums: Jörg Michael
Keyboards: Jens Johansson
Bass: Jari Kainulainen
Vocals: Timo Kotipelto / Michael Kiske / Mark Boals
In other words, STRATOVARIUS!

Basicly!
I can agree with that!

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 9:51 pm
by Melody of the sea
Hum, let me see...
Vocals: Michael Kiske (Helloween)
Drums: Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater)
Keyboards: Jens Johansson (Stratovarius)
Bass: Cliff Burton (Metallica)
Guitars: Kiko Loureiro and Rafael Bittencourt (both of Angra)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 11:41 pm
by Stealth
neonlightchild wrote:i've already post this in another topic a while ago, but...nevermind
In a melodic metal band:
Vocals: Tony Kakko(Sonata Arctica)
Guitar: Michael Romeo (Symphony X)
Guitar: Kiko Loureiro (Angra)
Bass: Billy Sheehan (Vai)
Drums: Ulli Kusch (Masterplan)
No keyboards?!?!?!?
Here goes; I've chosen more than one for some categories because it is just too hard to choose

:
Drums: Carlos Cantatore (Skylark until very recently

)
Bass: Patrick Vir (Forgotten Tales)
Guitars: Yngwie Malmsteen, Norifumi Shima (Concerto Moon)
Keyboards: Jens Johansson (err, Strato), Richard Andersson (Majestic/Time Requiem/Space Odyssey), Toshiyuki Koike (Concerto Moon)
Vocals: Roy Khantatat (Kamelot - his full last name is so much better than "Khan"

), John West (Royal Hunt)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 3:04 am
by Painless_Cry
timo kotipelto (vocals)
Anneke van giersbergen (vocals)
Tuomas Holopaienen (keys)
Alexi laiho (guitar)
jukka (drums)
Jari (bass)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 4:54 am
by stratoplayer
ok lets see
drums: either Jorg or Mike portnoy (so what, he rules even if he plays with DT

)
bass: hmm, dont really have a favorite bass player, maybe Jari (loved him in stratofortress, destiny, i walk to my own song, million light years away...)
singer: Female ; tarja from nightwish (i like SOME of their songs, but she is fantastic when vocalizing)
male: either TK or Bruce Dickinson (i love his stance and voice)
keys: JENS, DUH!!!!!! or Alex Starpoli (i really like his classical arrangements)
guitar player; now this is where it gets interesting, Tolkki is my favorite guitar player so he is a must, but the second guitar player is either Van Halen or Steve Vai (completely different styles i know! that is what makes it interesting, imagine if they jammed together.....)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 11:10 am
by Mormegil
If talking of a melodic metal band:
Vocals: Rob "The Metal God" Halford / Ronnie James Dio
Guitar: Michael Weikath / Timo Tolkki / Glenn Tipton / Ritchie Blackmore
Bass: Steve Harris / Joey DeMaio
Gayboards: Jens Johansson
Drums: Daniel Zimmermann / Thomen Stauch
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 11:35 am
by MetalAngel
Three versions :
Vocals : Tobias Sammet
Guitars : Adrian Smith and Kiko Loureiro
Bass : Steve Harris
Drums : Aquiles Priester (the best drummer ever!)
Keys : Jens Johansson
OR
Vocals : Andre Matos
Vocals : Tobias Sammet
Guitars : Ronny Tegner, Roy Z, Adrian Smith, Mickael Weikath.
Bass : Tobias Exxel
Drums : Aquiles Priester
Keys : Tuomas Holopainen.
OR
Vocals : Me!
Guitars : Me!
Drums : Me!
Bass : Me!
Keys : My gf!

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 11:58 am
by Stealth
Morme-gil, there are no gayboards!!!! Keyboards absolutely RULEEEEAAAAARRRRGGGGHHHH!!!!!
MetalAngel: Aquiles Priester best drummer ever? His drum solo on Angra's dvd was not that great.... Jorg's solo on Visions of Europe and Anders' solo on one of HammerFall's dvd were FAR better. Still, Aquiles is not bad at all

, but the hidden treasure is Carlos Cantatore!
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 12:09 pm
by MetalAngel
Well, Mike Terrana is also not so bad as a drummer. I saw his solo on a video with his former band, before he played with Rage. Amazing. But, the fact that he bate himself on his head, while he was playing double bass drum, was strange and ridiculous...

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 7:36 pm
by Paulo
To be honest, I found it really hard to pick a bassist. I can't think of one that really stands out. Dirk's got comedy value though. He'd make the inlay sleeves really funny with his comedy poses.
It was a real toss-up between Jorg or Dan for drums. And it was equally close between TK and Tobias. I'll probably change my mind later on.
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 9:08 am
by htcdude
Vocals: Frank Sinatra
Guitar: Bob Seeger
Guitar: Jens Johanssen
Bass: Mike Portnoy
Keyboards: Joe Satriani
Drums: Mr. Kotipelto
Well it'd be intresting

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 10:29 am
by Stealth
htcdude wrote:Vocals: Frank Sinatra
Guitar: Bob Seeger
Guitar: Jens Johanssen
Bass: Mike Portnoy
Keyboards: Joe Satriani
Drums: Mr. Kotipelto
Well it'd be intresting

Actually, you can see HammerFall doing that in one of their many DVDs (they play a cover of Judas Priest's "Breaking the Law"). I don't remember all of the switches, but I do remember that Joacim Cans played the guitar and Oscar Dronjak sang (horrible!!!!!!!!

).
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 11:44 am
by metalman
Vocals - Geoff Tate / Timo Tolkki
Keys - Jens Johansson
Drums - Mike Portnoy
Bass - Cliff Burton
Guitar - Randy Rhoads / Yngwie Malmsteen
Guitar - Chris DeGarmo
This could be nice
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 12:22 pm
by MetalAngel
htcdude wrote:Vocals: Frank Sinatra
Guitar: Bob Seeger
Guitar: Jens Johanssen
Bass: Mike Portnoy
Keyboards: Joe Satriani
Drums: Mr. Kotipelto
Well it'd be intresting

Yes, it would!

Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 2:58 pm
by NeonVomit
htcdude wrote:We had this topic a while ago, DragonForce

*sigh* maybe you'll one day realise they're not the only band in the world, and power metal isn't the only genre...
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 5:30 pm
by Leo
Gitar:Malmsteen
Keyboard: Jens Johanson
Drums: Tjodalv (ex. Dimmu)
Bass:Stu Hamm (Playd with Joe satriani)
Vokal:Kotipelto/Simone (Epica)
Scream: Mark Jansen (epica, ex After forever)
Re: Who would be in your all-star metal band?
Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 5:53 pm
by metal_4_life14
Drums : Mike terrana or Mike Portnoy or J. Michael
Keyboards : Jens johansson

and nobody else
Bass : Steve Harris
Lead guitar : Malmsteen
Rythmic guitar : J. Schaffer
Singer : mmm difficult choice i like a lot of vocalist : T. Kotipelto, B. Dickinson, A. Matos, M. Vescera, M. Tramp, M. Kiske, F. Lione, T. Sammet, J. Scott Sotto, H. Hess...