And, you are damned right I am selfish when it comes to my kid--you'll be a parent one day, and you'll understand.......on second thought, skip it.....
Understood and that makes you a good mother. But I think when discussing politics, your arguments against the war should be aimed more directly at other aspects of the situation rather than at your son. War is a horrible thing because it leads to death. Death is inevitable. But if you think about your son every time when it comes to war, chances are you're not going to be making a lot of correct decisions.
In any case, there isn't even a draft, so why make your son such a large part of your anti-war stance?
BTW, there have been people on this Forum who have been VEHEMENTLY Anti-American--I'm sure the posts are still here--BUT, FifthTea, I NEVER saw you take THEM on. Why is that
There are several reasons.
1. A lot of people on this forum are so off-track about the truths (claiming 9/11 is a hoax, etc) that it is ridiculus to, no matter how anti-american they are, have a decent discussion with them.
2. A lot of people resort to insults when it comes to an argument on the forums, instead of sticking to the facts and continuing to the discussion. I'm talking about say that \m/ killer guy out there who after hearing my political views started posting in every thread I posted with a nasty political or personal remark (not just the times when I made a statement myself).
3. I could go on, but there are a lot of things I have to discuss and I don't have much time today
Having served in the military myself, i don't think it's a 'small' risk. The Iraq war is wrong, simple as that.
First of all, the percentage of soldiers who went to Iraq and died is perhaps .8% or a similar figure to that. It really isn't as much a risk as you make it seem. And if the Iraq war is wrong, "simple as that", it really doesn't matter, because the country together chose, the congress chose, to fight.
Lets just assume for a second that there weren't ANY WMD's, a valid assumption too, considering the circumstance. And lets assume that Saddam wasn't all that big of a threat to the United States of America. Granted, for the sake of this argument. But what is so horrible about going and liberating a country from Saddam? Do you think he was a good man? Do you for a second think that invading Iraq and freeing the Iraqi's was a bad thing?
Maybe if it wasn't a threat to the US, it wasn't a practical move financially for the United States, but how can you say that the overall result of this war wasn't/isn't a good one? These people had an election, they're having a constitution, things are looking up and in a few years they'll be even able to take care of themselves.
So if one believes American soldiers going and liberating Iraq is that horrible a cause that one have to turn your back on the countries decision, I don't know what to say.
who deserted his own military duty
National Guard.
Okay, but does her alleged ashamedness make her opinion irrelevant, and if so, why?
It just goes to show that she doesn't respect her country. Thats all. I'm not saying it makes her opinion irrelevant, but it isn't a good thing to say.
Of course she doesn't, nor do I believe Stratoplayer was saying that.
I think if you take some time to really read what he said, you'll see thats exactly what he was saying.
So, in other words, if someone thinks everything is shit, rather than trying to understand why that someone feels that way, that someone should just shut up?
Its not my job to understand what she feels, its her job to explain it. But one should be a little more thorough when insulting her country, because someone might get the wrong idea. And I got the wrong idea. And it wasn't a wrong idea after all, it seems. It was correct, she hates USA.
Aah, but you claimed this forum to be "an international forum where everyone is trying to look for an excuse to bash USA anyway" (emphasis mine).
Now, if people want to have crackpot theories about 9/11, by all means. But that wasn't what I was defending.
It is a forum where everyone is looking for an excuse to bash the USA. Simply, in many cases (not all) that is fueled by international propoganda. I don't even know why we're arguing in the first place, nordicstorm. I don't know what you're defending. I suppose its CC.
I'm not sure I follow. Why is it unacceptable?
I find disagreeing with your countries policies acceptable. I find outright hating your country just because x didn't win unacceptable. Do you still need clarification on this?
Eeh. So if I were to write an essay criticizing the elitist nature of Finnish society or perhaps the less-than-stellar Finnish involvement in WWII, I should reconsider doing so, because I'm connoting a tone when I wrote "elitist nature" and "less-than-stellar"?
No, but having your essay say: "Finnish people are a bunch of communist losers, who amount to nothing. We can all go to hell" is wrong coming from a person who lives in Finland, born and raised. There is a distinct border between constructive criticism and outright hate for your country.
Well, you oughta get something in return for paying taxes, right?
Yes, but that should not be the only premise of you staying in the country.
You don't think that Cindy Sheehan character making the news lately is slightly, oh I don't know, pissed off about her son's death?
Don't even get me started on her! Oops too late.
She is a complete
moron .
I mean what a selfish fool.
She was alright with her son going and fighting in Iraq when he was getting paid for it, but when something happened to him, the entire principles of the war turn upside down? Shame on her!
She doesn't realize that to do the right thing, you have to make a sacrifice. If she was so against the war, she shouldn't have encouraged her son to go to Iraq. And if she didn't encourage him and he went on his own free will even when she was against it, he died with honor and she should respect that.
She thinks that just because her son died, the USA should pull out of Iraq, effectively
screwing the Iraqi population, having a regime worse than Hussein take over? Bush even met with her, what exactly does she want? She is a fool!
Oh, I forgot--5thTea does not have a sense of humor, so we better watch ourselves
Correct.
Hrm no, see this joke:
Ahh screw this, I have nothing.