NeonVomit wrote:Just because he planned something, it doesn't mean he was evil. I work with people with mental difficulties a lot. If someone as potentially dangerous as this guy is left unchecked, there is every chance their minds will follow the path to this sort of violence.
I think that Cho certainly exhibited plenty of warning signs, unfortunately, most states have laws that if a person, mentally ill or not, does not want help, then they can only be held under court order in a treatment center for a very small period of time.
NeonVomit wrote:Sure, people can be crazy and evil. (What is 'evil' in any case though? A subject for another discussion.
Why be rhetorical about the question of evil? It abounds in this world today, and does it
really need a definition?
NeonVomit wrote:I don't really believe in the Devil or anything...) I don't think this guy was evil though. He was deranged, living in his own world.
I think that what this guy did was certainly evil, and if it had happened at your school, or to your friends or family, I think you might look at it a bit differently. I believe that this guy is fully accountable for his actions.
NeonVomit wrote:Are you saying he's in hell now? Even though he was completely out of touch with reality and most probably unaware of what he was really doing? That wouldn't be very fair, if you ask me.
The Bible says, "Each shall be judged according to his own works," and I believe that those words are true. I believe that God will forgive any sin, with the sole exception of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, which as I've said before, is a sin that I believe that no one alive today can even commit.
However, how could Cho ask for forgiveness after he is already dead? Once a mortal dies and is buried, there is no returning to this world.
I cannot say with any type of authority where his soul is now, since I am, quite obviously, not God. I do have my suspicions, based on what I have seen, though.
For what it's worth, I ran across an interesting article on your question that is part of a column that is written by Fox News Religious Correspondent, Father Jonathan Morris.
foxnews.com/fatherjonathan
Father Jonathan, who is a Catholic priest, answered readers' questions about the VT tragedy. The most interesting reply was to Dr. Ken, a physician from Maryland, who, like myself, believes that Cho made a conscientious choice to do what he did, and is therefore, fully accountable for what he did. Like yourself, Father Jonathan was not so sure if he agreed with the doctor, and said so in his reply. Here is Father Jonathan's response to Dr. Ken:
RESPONSE: Dr. Ken, thanks for your note, including the part I didn’t have room to include. I wanted to comment on this first paragraph, though, because I think we need to be careful not to jump to the conclusion that Cho is fully culpable before God for the “choice” to pull the trigger. Some people wrote to me to say we know for sure Cho is in hell. I surely don’t. Especially in the case of mental illness, things aren’t so simple.
NeonVomit wrote:If he'd been taken seriously earlier, right now he'd be in a mental institution receiving the therapy and care he required, and who knows... maybe one day might have made a recovery back to being an everyday person. Then he wouldn't end up in hell would he?
A Virginia judge actually did have this guy committed for short-term treatment, and it is apparent that he lied to the therapists who assessed him. The official report said that while he was an "imminent" threat to himself, the study could not find that he was a threat to others.
It is very difficult for me to find any shred of sympathy for people that commit acts such as these though. My sympathy is with the victims, and moreover, there families as well. Cho was the perpetrator, in my opinion, and not the victim.
Regarding your question of therapy preventing him from going to hell, I don't think that therapy alone would have prevented it. There are times where God's direct intervention is needed.
Only salvation keeps us out of hell, and the therapy that this guy would have required would most likely have included heavy doses of meds, and long-term in-patient care. Was he insane? Most likely, but I would have considered him to be criminally insane, as he was consumed with violent hatred for just about everyone.
I do think that he had a crucifixion complex, though, and the whole thing with him having "Ismail Ax" (Ismail is a derivative of Ishmael) written on his arm, in red, leads to other possibilities, such as demonic possession. With that, you
might have a gray area.
NeonVomit wrote:I'm not playing devil's advocate here, but perhaps the responsibility of this tragedy lies elsewhere
Yes, I could see that- perhaps with the Devil that no one seems to believe in, anymore? As I said previously, you may not believe in him as a spiritual entity, but don't you think that it's safe to say that his agenda is at least alive and well?